DC PENSION PLAN
2 types: plan sponsor-directed plan, participant-directed plan*
Investment issue:
1) Diversification: Sponsor must offer a menu of >3 investment choices diversified and allow participant to move freely among options (ERISA)
2) Company stock: Holdings of sponsor-company stock should be limited to allow participant's wealth to be adequately diversified.
A DC investment policy statement establishes procedures to ensure a myriad of individual investor objectives and constraints can be properly addressed. It is the governing document that describes the investment strategies and alternatives available to the group of plan participants characterized by diverse objective and constraints. (not for specific plan participant)
Plan sponsor provide education resources for participant choosing plan reflecting his own presonal financial circumstances, goal and attitude towards risk, but not counsel the participant. The employee need to educate himself about risk and return, objective and constraint.
Fund should evaluated on time horizon of >2years.
Fund should evaluated relative to benchmark similar investment style (peer group)
HYBRID PLAN and employee stock ownership plan (ESOP)
Example: cash balance plan*, pension equity plans, target benefit plans and floor plans.
Combine good DC feature (portability, administrative ease, understandability by participants) and good DB feature (benefit guarantees, year of service rewards, the ability to link retirement pay to a percentage of salary)
ESOP are DC plans that invest all or the majority of plan assets in employer stock.
ESOP have been used by companies to liquidate a large block of company stock held by an individual or small group of people; avoid a public offering of stock; discourage an unfriendly takeover by placing a large holding of stock in the hands of employee via ESOP trust.
More risky: lack of diversification in terms of human capital and financial
Saturday, October 30, 2010
Institutional investor portfolio (DB Pension Plan)
- Pension plan consist of define benefit plan (DB) and define contribution plan (DC). There are also hybrid such as cash balance plan.
- Cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan whose benefits are displayed in individual recordkeeping accounts. These account show the participant the current value of his or her accrued benefit and facilitate portability to a new plan.
- Actuary split the plan liability between retired and active live(employees)
Greater cash outflow if greater number of retired live; Greater percentage of retiree has shorter average life or duration of future pension liabilities.
RISK OBJECTIVE: (Factor affecting)
1) Plan status: Higher pension surplus or higher funded status implies greater risk tolerance.
2) Sponsor financial status and profibility: Lower debt ratio and higher current and expected profibility imply greater risk tolerance.
3) Sponsor and pension fund common risk exposures: The lower the correlation, the greater risk tolerances
4) Plan features: Features (eg provision for early retirement, provision for lump sum distribution) tend to reduce the duration of plan liabilities, imply lower risk tolerance.
5) Workforce characteristics: The younger the workforce and the greater the proportion of active livesm the greater the duration of plan liabilities and the greater the risk tolerance.
If the plan is not fully funded, the plan sponsor has an obligation to make contribution to the plan. The sponsor's financial strength and profibility can affect the sponsor's ability and willingness to make such contributions when needed. It is worse when the operating results are highly correlated with pension asset return. The size of pension contribution increase when the operating results are weak.
Notes on risk management:
Risk relative to liabilities is important and the asset/liabilities management (ALM) perspective on risk and on investing is a primary concern. ALM is a subset of a company's overall risk management practise that typically focuses on financial risks created by the interaction of asset and liabilities; for a given financial liabilities, ALM involves managing the investment of assets to control relative asset/liabilities values. Relative means the volatility of surplus is lower if changes in the value of plan assets are positively correlated with changes in the value of plan liabilities. Because pension plan are interest rate sensitive, pension plan sponsors emphasizing an ALM approach tend to make more intensive use of interest-rate sensitive securities (Bond) than would otherwise be the case.
DB plan risk objective: ALM in DB means
1) pension surplus volatility (SD) 2) shortfall risk (100% funded, above some level to avoid reporting pension liability; above ERISA level trigger additional contribution; above PBGC level that trigger increase premium if underfunded
RETURN OBJECTIVE
Basically to achieve return that adequately fund its pension liabilities on an inflation adjusted basis. or set a specify numerical return objective.
Return objective relating to future pension contributions: to make future pension contribution equal to zero. When the pension plan is fully funded, return requirement should equal to discount rate used to calculate pension liabilities.
Return objective related to pension income: when strong financial market performance, pension expenses might be negative, sponsor company report pension income , objective is to maintain pension income.
LIQUIDITY REQUIREMENT
- The greater the number of retired lives, the greater the liquidity requirement. Declining industry may have a growing retired-lives portion.
- Smaller corporate contribution in relation to benifit disbursements, the greater the liquidity requirement
- Option to take early retirement and/or the option of retirees to take lump-sum payments need higher liquidity needs.
TIME HORIZON (factor)
- whether the plan is going concern or plan termination is expected
- the age of workforce and the proportion of active lives.
TAX CONCERN
- usually tax exempt. but contribution, termination, distribution to beneficiaries involve tax issues.
UNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCES
- Due to limited resources, small pension plan cannot afford alternative investment (hedge fund, private equity, natural resources) that required complex due diligence.
- Cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan whose benefits are displayed in individual recordkeeping accounts. These account show the participant the current value of his or her accrued benefit and facilitate portability to a new plan.
- Actuary split the plan liability between retired and active live(employees)
Greater cash outflow if greater number of retired live; Greater percentage of retiree has shorter average life or duration of future pension liabilities.
RISK OBJECTIVE: (Factor affecting)
1) Plan status: Higher pension surplus or higher funded status implies greater risk tolerance.
2) Sponsor financial status and profibility: Lower debt ratio and higher current and expected profibility imply greater risk tolerance.
3) Sponsor and pension fund common risk exposures: The lower the correlation, the greater risk tolerances
4) Plan features: Features (eg provision for early retirement, provision for lump sum distribution) tend to reduce the duration of plan liabilities, imply lower risk tolerance.
5) Workforce characteristics: The younger the workforce and the greater the proportion of active livesm the greater the duration of plan liabilities and the greater the risk tolerance.
If the plan is not fully funded, the plan sponsor has an obligation to make contribution to the plan. The sponsor's financial strength and profibility can affect the sponsor's ability and willingness to make such contributions when needed. It is worse when the operating results are highly correlated with pension asset return. The size of pension contribution increase when the operating results are weak.
Notes on risk management:
Risk relative to liabilities is important and the asset/liabilities management (ALM) perspective on risk and on investing is a primary concern. ALM is a subset of a company's overall risk management practise that typically focuses on financial risks created by the interaction of asset and liabilities; for a given financial liabilities, ALM involves managing the investment of assets to control relative asset/liabilities values. Relative means the volatility of surplus is lower if changes in the value of plan assets are positively correlated with changes in the value of plan liabilities. Because pension plan are interest rate sensitive, pension plan sponsors emphasizing an ALM approach tend to make more intensive use of interest-rate sensitive securities (Bond) than would otherwise be the case.
DB plan risk objective: ALM in DB means
1) pension surplus volatility (SD) 2) shortfall risk (100% funded, above some level to avoid reporting pension liability; above ERISA level trigger additional contribution; above PBGC level that trigger increase premium if underfunded
RETURN OBJECTIVE
Basically to achieve return that adequately fund its pension liabilities on an inflation adjusted basis. or set a specify numerical return objective.
Return objective relating to future pension contributions: to make future pension contribution equal to zero. When the pension plan is fully funded, return requirement should equal to discount rate used to calculate pension liabilities.
Return objective related to pension income: when strong financial market performance, pension expenses might be negative, sponsor company report pension income , objective is to maintain pension income.
LIQUIDITY REQUIREMENT
- The greater the number of retired lives, the greater the liquidity requirement. Declining industry may have a growing retired-lives portion.
- Smaller corporate contribution in relation to benifit disbursements, the greater the liquidity requirement
- Option to take early retirement and/or the option of retirees to take lump-sum payments need higher liquidity needs.
TIME HORIZON (factor)
- whether the plan is going concern or plan termination is expected
- the age of workforce and the proportion of active lives.
TAX CONCERN
- usually tax exempt. but contribution, termination, distribution to beneficiaries involve tax issues.
LEGAL AND REGULATION FACTORS
ERISA - US. Standard of care that pension plan sponsors must meet in making investment decisions.
A trustee is legally responsible for ensuring that assets are managed solely in the interest of beneficiariesUNIQUE CIRCUMSTANCES
- Due to limited resources, small pension plan cannot afford alternative investment (hedge fund, private equity, natural resources) that required complex due diligence.
- self-imposed constraint against investing in certain industries view as having ethical problem.
Thursday, October 28, 2010
Life insurance (a hedge against mortality risk)
When income highly correlated with risky asset, asset allocation become more conservative and demand for life insurance decrease, because lower human capital induce lower demand for insurance. Less money spend on life insurance indirectly increase the amount of financial wealth the investor can invest, so the investor can invest more in risk free assets to reduce the risk associated with her total wealth.
Optimal asset allocation to risk free asset increase with initial wealth. Demand for insurance decrease with financial wealth.
Risk averse (conservative) should buy more insurance, and invest more in risk free asset
High bequest motive (highly concern about their heirs) should buy more insurance.
Insurance demand drop as one's get older because less human capital. Magnitude of loss of human capital at younger ages is far more important than the higher probability of death at older ages.
Investor with lower subjective survival probablity (i.e., those who believe they have a high mortality rate) will tend to buy more life insurance.
Optimal asset allocation to risk free asset increase with initial wealth. Demand for insurance decrease with financial wealth.
Risk averse (conservative) should buy more insurance, and invest more in risk free asset
High bequest motive (highly concern about their heirs) should buy more insurance.
Insurance demand drop as one's get older because less human capital. Magnitude of loss of human capital at younger ages is far more important than the higher probability of death at older ages.
Investor with lower subjective survival probablity (i.e., those who believe they have a high mortality rate) will tend to buy more life insurance.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)